AstraI 1.4T 140CP versus GolfVI 1.4T 122CP

Si traducerea data de Google. In engleza ca in romana o face varza. Adevarat, a consumat cca 0.3 litri mai putin, in rest.....

Crown in the compact class is from 5 December 2009 in the sixth round. Then start the new Astra. In IMAGE, the two were already competed against each other. Cool, clean lines in the Golf 1.4 TSI (122 hp, from 21,655 euros) to playful extravagance in the Astra 1.4 Turbo (140 hp, from 19,075 euros). Pure matter of taste. Point for both - 1:1. The Astra, the eye moves through a V-shaped center console, in the Gulf, I have everything immediately in view. I bring forward my 1.93 meters in both equally good at, I'm sitting back deeper in the Astra, a bit more headroom have. Again a draw. 2:2. Both have 1.4-liter turbo gasoline engine, only raise their voices on the highway. The 18-more hp in the Astra I feel subjectively driving difficult. But at the pump: Opel consumed nearly half a liter less. Disappointing for both: no start-stop automatic, no gear shift indicator. Nonetheless point for Opel: 3-2.
This is the brand new pages of autobild.de
The Astra prima stays on course, steering input is needed to quickly and accurately. That the Golf offers more comfort, because he is more relaxed on bumpy tracks. Draw - 4:3. The Astra is cheaper than 2500 euro, the lower insurance ratings. But the Gulf is much better equipped (eg, air-conditioning as standard) and is expected to have lower depreciation. Draw. 5:4. PICTURE Verdict: The Astra wins because of lower consumption. Builds a pity that the Opel Astra only in England and Poland, but not in Germany.
Specifications
Opel Astra 1.4 Turbo Golf 1.4 TSI
Engine 4-cylinder gasoline engine 4-cyl petrol engine
Power 140 hp 122 hp
0-100 km / h 9.7 seconds 9.5 seconds
Top speed 205 km / h 200 km / h
Consumption to 5.9 liters 6.2 liters of Super
CO2 emissions 139 g / km 144 g / km
Price 19,075 Euro 21,655 Euro

vw are fabrici prin mexic, unde calitatea e la ea acasa. Chiar putin spicy

mie imi plac mult ambele.e o decizie grea

Eu prefer Noul Astra...Golf VI mi se pare doar un facelift al lui Golf V.Cu toate acestea trebuie sa recunosc ca interiorul Golfului nou e destul de interesant,dar e undeva la egalitate cu cel al Astrei.

sa stii cai ai perfecta dreptate si eu unu prefel tot astra in locul golfului cred ca si aici era binevenit un chestionar nu?

Astra i sau j ?

argumente bune, dar chiar daca nu iei in considerare designul(ASTRA RULES), de ce ar trebui sa scoti 2600 eur in plus pt un golf care este egal atat la dotare cat si la performante.

Fara indoiala ASTRA ii masina!

Astra ar fi alegerea in conditiile in care golf-ul e mai scum cu aprox 2000E cam cu aceeasi echipare.

Am votat astra pentru ca este mai puternica si imi place mai mult per total decat golful

Clar astra: este mult mai frumoasa decat golful, plus ca este mai puternica si mai ieftina. VW sunt cam "naspa". De ex un golf IV 1.6 16v consuma mai mult decat Vectra B2 1.8 16v( de performanta nu mai discutam, nu se pot compara).